I have to set this up.
There’s a musician I absolutely love. Grammy-winning, critic’s darling, all that. Moment I heard her first CD, I thought it redefined the folk genre. Second release? No sophomore slump here. On the third, although darker lyrically, it hit on all cylinders. But on her fourth, she hit the wall in my mind. Songs didn’t have the same edge, and it didn’t do well commercially or critically. Gave it a pass though. Figured, she’s earned enough cred with the previous three.
Until the other day, when I checked out her latest and fifth, and well, I didn’t get it. It was the antithesis of everything she did musically on her first. It was, for lack of a better word, safe. Gone was the dark edge, the moody exploration of relationships past, not to mention the intriguing harmonies and chord progressions I’d not heard before in folk. I’d read she’d gone through some life changes recently, and rationalized to myself that maybe this was the reason. But then I had a thought that I’ve never had before about an actor, artist, musician or athlete:
It’s my fault.
Doesn’t matter if I like it, the performer does what they do for themselves first. They have to. Otherwise, they end up changing their style to fit the audience and compromising the work. I’d been in a groove for those first three CDs and expected more of the same. After all, don’t people naturally prefer what’s comfortable to them? Don’t change things too much. Give them their drink, their TV and their favorite chair.
Which is how I get with music and movies. I make a connection to the work someone does, and like a drug, need more and more of what it is they do in the style they do it. Wise? Probably not. Because after being disappointed over this latest release, I realized that while people hate change, there’s something more important at work here for the artist:
They need change.
If they don’t, forget compromising the work – they die as artists. Like the shark that has to keep swimming or it dies, the artist has to change or they die. The best we can hope for is that we’re in tune with their work for as long as possible, but eventually, they may go in a different direction from where we expect them to go. And there’s not a thing we can do about it.
Nor should we.